Under the FIDIC 2017 Red and Yellow Books, a time or money claim follows the same Clause 20 procedure: a Notice of Claim no later than 28 days after the claiming party became aware, or should have become aware, of the event, then a fully detailed claim within 84 days, including the contractual or legal basis. Miss those steps and Sub-Clause 20.2.1 says the claiming party is not entitled to additional payment or an extension of time. What differs is the substance of the claim. Red Book claims usually arise from employer-designed works, variations, late drawings, remeasurement and unforeseeable physical conditions. Yellow Book claims usually turn on the Employer’s Requirements, design responsibility and whether a change is a variation or design development. In the GCC, particular conditions and local civil codes often tighten those rules further, so managers must apply the signed contract and local law, not only the unamended book.
The same 2017 claims clock, two different risk models
FIDIC published the second editions of the Red, Yellow and Silver Books in 2017. The Red Book remains the Conditions of Contract for Construction for building and engineering works designed by the employer. The Yellow Book remains the Conditions of Contract for Plant and Design-Build, for works designed by the contractor. A Fenwick Elliott paper for the Society of Construction Law sets out how the 2017 suite split claims and disputes: claims sit in Clause 20, and disputes sit in Clause 21, with a Dispute Avoidance/Adjudication Board (DAAB) procedure before arbitration: https://www.fenwickelliott.com/sites/default/files/scl_-_the_new_2017_fidic_red_yellow_and_silver_books_with_scl_logo-1.pdf.
That split is easy to miss if a team still works from 1999 clause numbers. In the 1999 Red Book, contractor claims were centred on Sub-Clause 20.1 and the Dispute Adjudication Board lived in the same clause family. In 2017, the claims process is more prescriptive for both the contractor and the employer. The Engineer then agrees or determines the claim under Sub-Clause 3.7.
The Clause 20.2 sequence managers should diary
Fenwick Elliott quotes Sub-Clause 20.2.1: the claiming party must give a Notice of Claim to the Engineer describing the event or circumstance “as soon as practicable, and no later than 28 days” after it became aware, or should have become aware, of that event. If it fails to do so, it “shall not be entitled to any additional payment”, the Time for Completion “shall not be extended”, and the other party is discharged from liability in connection with the event.
A fully detailed claim is then due within 84 days after the claiming party became aware, or should have become aware, of the event. The parties can agree with the Engineer to extend that period. If the claiming party fails to set out the contractual or other legal basis in time, the original Notice of Claim is deemed to have lapsed, subject to the challenge route in Sub-Clause 20.2.5. Contemporary records are part of the fully detailed claim, not an optional annex to be assembled later.
The Engineer’s initial response also matters. If the Engineer considers the notice late, it must say so within 14 days; otherwise the notice may be treated as valid. That is a practical reason for both employers and contractors to log incoming notices on the day they arrive.
These time-bars are written as conditions precedent in the unamended 2017 text. Whether a GCC court or tribunal will always enforce them is a separate question. The International Bar Association’s April 2024 Qatar survey records that there has been no definitive Qatari court ruling, and that good faith, abuse of rights and mandatory prescription rules can be argued either way: https://www.ibanet.org/fidic-clint-april-2024-qatar. Managers should still comply with the 28-day and 84-day steps. Relying on a later legal argument is a weak project-controls strategy.
Where Red Book claims usually arise
On a Red Book project the employer is responsible for the design and the contractor builds it, typically with a bill of quantities and an Engineer who administers the contract, certifies payment and determines claims. The common claim events are variations, remeasurement, late or changed drawings and instructions, and unforeseeable physical conditions.
For GCC public and giga-project work, the practical burden is contemporary evidence: the drawing-issue register, site instructions, agreed records of physical conditions, resource records and a cause-and-effect delay analysis tied to the programme in the contract. A narrative that the “employer delayed the works” is not a fully detailed claim.
Because design risk sits with the employer, contractors should still warn of design defects they ought to discover. In several GCC civil codes, including Qatar, decennial liability can make the contractor and the engineer jointly liable for collapse or defects that threaten structural integrity, and a contractor who proceeds without warning may share that liability.
Where Yellow Book claims usually arise
On a Yellow Book project the contractor designs and builds to the Employer’s Requirements. The Engineer still administers the contract, but design liability sits with the contractor. Disputes often turn on what the Employer’s Requirements actually required, whether they contained an error, and whether a later change is a variation or merely the contractor developing its own design.
That distinction is the one middle and senior managers should force into the kick-off meeting. If the employer’s team comments on contractor design as if it were an employer-led Red Book review, it can create a variation by instruction, or at least a claim that one was given. If the contractor treats every clarification of its own design as a variation, the claim will fail. Yellow Book claim files need the design history, the comment logs, and a clause-by-clause reading of the Employer’s Requirements, not only site diaries.
Yellow Book packages are common in the GCC on process plant, power, water and infrastructure where the employer specifies the outcome and the contractor provides the solution. ICLG’s 2026 UAE construction guide notes that the FIDIC 1999 suite remains the primary standard form in the UAE, so many live projects will still be on 1999 clause numbers even when the commercial model is design-build: https://iclg.com/practice-areas/construction-and-engineering-law-laws-and-regulations/uae/. Do not apply 2017 time-bars to a 1999 contract, or 1999 habits to a 2017 contract.
How GCC particular conditions and local law change the picture
In Qatar, the IBA survey records that government and public entities such as the Public Works Authority (Ashghal), Kahramaa and QatarEnergy (named there as Qatar Petroleum) usually use FIDIC Red Book forms for employer-designed construction, and Yellow Book forms where the contractor designs and constructs. Arabic is generally required in government contracts under Law No. 7 of 2019 on the Protection of the Arabic Language, often with a parallel English text. Delay damages in contracts with Qatari public entities are capped at 10 per cent of the contract price, and pre-agreed damages may be reduced if they do not reflect actual loss, are grossly exaggerated, or the obligation was only partly performed. Dispute boards have not gained much traction in Qatar.
In Saudi Arabia, Pinsent Masons reports that most FIDIC contracts still follow the 1999 suite, including on several Vision 2030 projects, and that DABs are often removed in favour of SCCA arbitration: https://www.pinsentmasons.com/out-law/guides/using-fidic-construction-contracts-in-saudi-arabia. Financing-charge clauses are commonly deleted because of the prohibition of riba. The Civil Transactions Law also affects liquidated damages and unforeseen circumstances, as discussed in KE Leaders’ companion article on FIDIC and Vision 2030.
In the UAE, FIDIC remains the most common standard form, and ICLG notes that parties often amend the general conditions and should also consider the Civil Transactions Law, Federal Law No. 25 of 2025, especially Articles 812 to 839. Public procurement sits under a different layer of federal and emirate rules, covered in KE Leaders’ Qatar and UAE contract-management article.
Across the Gulf, employers frequently shorten notice periods, limit extensions of time and additional cost, restrict the Engineer’s independence, and delete or modify dispute boards. The claims procedure you trained on is only the starting point.
A practical claims discipline for both books
Keep a clause-departure schedule that records every change to Clause 20, Clause 21, variations and exceptional events. Diary the 28-day and 84-day dates, or the shorter periods in the particular conditions, for both contractor and employer claims. Build contemporary records as the work proceeds. On Red Book jobs, control the drawing and instruction register. On Yellow Book jobs, control the Employer’s Requirements, design submissions and comment logs. Train commercial, planning and delivery teams together so a notice is issued when the event is known, not when the final cost is known.
KE Leaders is a CIPS and ATHE approved training centre in Ilford, London, and trains GCC contract, claims and project teams on both the 1999 and 2017 suites.
Related KE Leaders courses
- دبلوم مهني في إدارة مطالبات وعقود الاتحاد الدولي للمهندسين الاستشاريين (FIDIC)
- شهادة متقدمة في المطالبات وتسوية المنازعات بموجب عقود الاتحاد الدولي للمهندسين الاستشاريين (FIDIC)
- FIDIC Mastery in Engineering and Design-Build Contracts Bootcamp
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the 28-day FIDIC 2017 notice a condition precedent in the GCC?
Unamended Sub-Clause 20.2.1 is drafted as a condition precedent. Enforcement can depend on local law. In Qatar, the IBA 2024 survey says there is no definitive court ruling and that good faith and mandatory prescription arguments may be raised. Comply with the notice anyway.
What is the 84-day deadline?
The fully detailed claim, including the contractual or legal basis, is due within 84 days of awareness of the event, unless the period is extended by agreement with the Engineer. Missing the legal basis can cause the notice to lapse.
Should a GCC public project use the Red Book or the Yellow Book?
Follow the design responsibility. IBA records that Qatari public entities typically use the Red Book where the employer issues the design and the Yellow Book where the contractor designs and builds. The tender documents decide.
Do 2017 rules apply if the contract is a 1999 form?
No. Many UAE and Saudi projects still use 1999 editions. Apply the edition in the signed contract.
Are dispute boards used in the GCC?
The 2017 suite provides for a DAAB under Clause 21, but practice varies. IBA says dispute boards are infrequently used in Qatar. Pinsent Masons reports that many Saudi FIDIC contracts remove the DAB in favour of SCCA arbitration.
Sources
- The new 2017 FIDIC Red, Yellow and Silver Books (Fenwick Elliott / SCL)
- FIDIC around the world — Qatar (International Bar Association)
- Construction and Engineering Laws and Regulations 2026: UAE (ICLG)
- Using FIDIC construction contracts in Saudi Arabia (Pinsent Masons)
Talk to KE Leaders
KE Leaders Training Centre can help your commercial, claims and project teams apply the 2017 Red and Yellow Books in GCC conditions. Email admin@keleaders.com, call 0044 7901 259494, or WhatsApp 0044 740 561 9940. This article is general training guidance, not legal advice. Always take advice on the signed contract and the official legal texts that apply to the project.

